I'm trying to clean up Area 51 proposals, and I came across this one:
Proposed Q&A site for beer writers, cicerones, professional brewers, and beer geeks
Would any of their on topic questions be off topic here?
(5 July) Edited to add:
The issues at hand here are:
- What percentage of their on topic questions would be on topic here?
- For subjects they want to be on topic, but which are currently off topic here—would this site consider broadening its scope to include those subjects as well?
What they consider to be off topic isn't relevant to this discussion.
(20 July) Edited to add:
A similar question has been asked at Area 51: How is this different from Homebrewing?